Baynes Sound oyster farmers are suing Cumberland over six-month closures
Oyster growers in Baynes Sound are suing the Village of Cumberland, arguing decades of wastewater mismanagement have cost the province's most productive oyster fishery millions in lost sales.
The lawsuit says overflow from the village's old wastewater lagoons forces the local shellfish fishery to close when heavy rainfall floods the system and sewage flows into the sound. Those closures can last up to six months and often land around Christmas, when sales should peak. Because oysters filter contaminants out of the water, the whole exposed area has to shut when fecal bacteria and viruses like norovirus turn up.
"It's really uncertain times when we can't reliably harvest for six months out of the year," said Malindi Taylor, a manager at Taylor Shellfish Canada, one of the plaintiffs. "It just completely cripples your business."
Mayor Vickey Brown called the timing "disappointing" and said the village is finishing a $22-million upgrade to its treatment system, including a UV filter capable of removing norovirus. She said she's confident the work will bring improvements this winter. Taylor isn't ready to exhale: "We'll see this winter how effective that really is," she said.


