Environment

A Cowichan Bay 24-year-old is suing Ottawa over its climate record, seven years after they filed at 17

Sierra Robinson is one of 15 young plaintiffs in La Rose v. His Majesty the King, which argues the federal government has never been legally bound to follow the climate plans it writes.

A Cowichan Bay 24-year-old is suing Ottawa over its climate record, seven years after they filed at 17
Capital Daily

Sierra Robinson was 17 when they signed onto a lawsuit against the Canadian government. They're 24 now, and the case has finally reached a courtroom.

The five-week trial of La Rose v. His Majesty the King began Monday at the Federal Court of Canada in Vancouver. Robinson, from Cowichan Bay, is one of 15 young plaintiffs arguing that Ottawa's emissions trajectory violates their Charter rights to life, liberty and security of the person, and that the Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act doesn't force Canada to hit the targets it sets.

Robinson told Capital Daily the case exposed something they found hard to believe. Ottawa, they said, argued in court that it has no legal obligation to carry out the climate plans it publishes. The plaintiffs aren't asking for money. They want the government ordered to build a science-based recovery plan.

Robinson won't take the stand because of chronic health issues, including stress-triggered seizures, but has attended every day to watch the others testify. Seven years after filing, the stakes are plainer than they were on the steps of the Vancouver Art Gallery in 2019: Canada's own environment commissioner now says the country is on track for a 28% emissions cut by 2030, not the 45% the law requires.

Capital Daily

Daily edition · Victoria

The morning habit · free

Tomorrow, wake up already knowing Victoria.

One email, every morning. What city hall decided, the place that just opened on Fort Street, the thing the whole Island will be talking about by noon — in a five-minute read, written by people who actually live here.

Independent Victoria news · 50,000 readers · unsubscribe anytime

The newsletter is free. The reporting isn’t.

Members fund the reporters who sat through that council meeting so you didn’t have to — $10/month keeps Victoria’s daily reading independent.

Wednesday deep dive · ad-free audio · early guides

Become a member · $10/mo Reader stays free, forever.

Was this worth your morning?